LEGO Creator Expert 77942 Fiat 500 limited edition comparison: blue is the new yellow [Review]

A few weeks ago, LEGO announced that they were running a trial in the UK to test variants of a few popular sets, altering their sizes or colors. The flagship model of this program is an update on last year’s Creator Expert 10271 Fiat 500, which overhauls the car’s light yellow to a light blue. The new set receives a new number, and 77942 Fiat 500 is sold from now until Nov. 30 through LEGO’s website in the UK (£74.99) or through retailer Zavvi. Unlike LEGO’s UK site, Zavvi does ship outside the UK, briefly allowing fans elsewhere in the world to get the set, though the first stock of Zavvi’s sets appears to have sold out and Zavvi has taken down the listing. LEGO has said that since it’s part of a trial program, once the set is sold out, it will not be available again. Today we’re taking a brief look at how the new blue Fiat compares to the yellow version we reviewed last year.


Unboxing the Fiats

The two boxes are nearly identical, since LEGO just performed some photoshop tweaks on the yellow model to give it its new hue. Our yellow box is a North American box with English, French, and Spanish, while the blue car is the European/Rest of World box, since it’s sold exclusively in the UK. Both sets contain 960 pieces and bear a 16+ rating, since the original packaging just barely predates LEGO’s shift to its LEGO For Adults black packaging and marketing-driven 18+ age rating. This may well be the last set to ever bear the Creator Expert branding.

Likewise, the back of the box retains all the same function callouts.

One difference I did note is that the blue Fiat box has glued ends with punch-out tabs to open the box, while the yellow model has sticker seals. Our original review copy of the yellow car was also a European box and it had sticker seals as well, so that doesn’t explain the difference. Personally, though, I don’t have a preference so it’s a distinction that makes no difference.


The contents

On its face, the conversion is simple. LEGO simply swapped all the 226 Cool Yellow (AKA Bright Light Yellow) elements to 212 Light Royal Blue (AKA Bright Light Blue). The set includes a pretty broad swath of elements in the key color, with 59 distinct elements coming in either yellow or blue. Many of the Cool Yellow elements were unique to the Fiat when it dropped last year, and so too many of the Light Royal Blue elements are unique to the update, as well. Here’s a small sampling of the blue elements.


Comparing the models

The instructions for the models are identical except for color, so the design of the finished models are the same in every way. Although we didn’t mention it in our initial review, some fans reported color discrepancies in the Cool Yellow bricks on the original. The yellow version I used for comparisons here was just purchased (and so isn’t part of the original production run) but it definitely has some minor color variations. They’re small and unlikely to be noticed by a casual builder, but fans who build a lot of LEGO will notice the small discrepancies, which in some cases appear from brick to brick within the same element. Thankfully, the Light Royal Blue seems to not suffer the same fate, as the color matching is quite consistent.

Besides the primary color in the bricks, though, the rest of the differences come from the stickers. The luggage in the back gains a Union Jack sticker, since the set is a UK exclusive.

Two of the original license plates styles referenced the set’s number, 10271, so the blue Fiat’s plates have been updated to match its new set number, 77942. An easy opportunity was missed here though to include UK plates for this UK variant. The TOFO 1965 plates are identical on both sets.

Similarly, it would have been nice if LEGO could have made even more distinction by swapping the car to be a right-hand drive suitable for UK roads. However, I think it’s understandable that LEGO chose to forego that update, for two reasons. First, that would have required re-validating the instructions (a lengthy process), and second, the entire point of this update is to see if a color-swap alone can affect sales, so altering the build (even in a seemingly innocuous way) would spoil that.

One final difference is apparent in the included painting. The original showed a yellow car, so obviously LEGO updated it to blue. A few other colors in the painting are changed as well, from the shading on the Colosseum to the foreground. Interestingly, the artist’s signature was dropped from the new version.


Conclusion

Color swaps on sets have been quite rare throughout LEGO’s history, though not entirely unheard of (e.g. 2148 LEGO Truck vs. 3442 LEGOLAND California Truck). While some of us liked the Fiat’s original Cool Yellow, many of us here at TBB were never fans of that color on the car, and no doubt many other people feel the same way. So an alternate color is welcome indeed, especially when it introduces a new color for a variety of elements. However, I do have some concerns about the way LEGO is handling this.

The Fiat 500 listings on the LEGO UK website

LEGO’s reasoning for introducing this color swap is to gauge how color influences buyers. Would someone be more tempted to spend $90 on a LEGO Fiat if it were light blue instead of light yellow? It’s a great thing to test, actually. The problem is that LEGO’s UK test market doesn’t operate in a vacuum, and LEGO is one of the hottest commodities in the toy market with not just fans but very avid collectors the world over, especially for sets like the Fiat which are marketed to adults. The mere fact that this set is being produced in limited quantities makes it of greater interest to LEGO fans and collectors. The new Fiat could have been rainbow-colored, and as long as the set was perceived as “exclusive” it would draw the interest of many fans and collectors, completely spoiling the data collection of which color is more desirable to the average fan. In fact, when we spoke with LEGO last month about the program before it was publicly announced, we asked LEGO how they planned to account for scalpers and were told that beyond limiting purchases to 1 per customer on the LEGO website, they had no plans in place. Retailer Zavvi did not have even this limitation, and in fact, marketed it as a special “Limited Edition” set—giving further evidence that data gathered from this test won’t be a true representation of which color fans actually prefer.

Secondly, LEGO promised in 2019 to make all regional exclusives available worldwide, either immediately or after a period of exclusivity. However, the sets in this program are to be available in the UK for just two months, and will not be available anywhere else after that period, a direct contradiction to LEGO’s promise. LEGO will no doubt argue that because this was a marketing test it’s different, but that’s little solace to the many fans outside the UK who are unable to get the set.

To be clear, I don’t think LEGO is sneakily trying to do a regional exclusive and just pass it off as a marketing test. I think rather that it was intended to be a real marketing test, but poorly designed and poorly executed such that it is effectively a regional exclusive of a fairly desirable set. The other sets in the experiment—two color variations on a small Creator dino, and two size variations on a City fire station—are of much less interest to the adult fan community and will possibly yield more useful data to LEGO.

It’s a great set, and if I consider only the design itself, I love that LEGO has made it. I like the blue much more than the original yellow, and having both versions is perfect for an adorable little commuter like the Fiat 500. I would love to recommend this set. However, I cannot. Much like we noted a few years ago in our review of the New York Comic-Con Star Wars BrickHeadz exclusives, while LEGO certainly has the right to create rare exclusives (even if they’re ostensibly marketing experiments), they do a disservice to their own fans when they do. After all, as we said about those BrickHeadz, “the vast majority among the tens of thousands of you out there reading this review can never own this set.” And so this poorly executed marketing test only serves as a way to frustrate fans, rather than as a way to gather insight on them.

77942 Fiat 500 (blue) contains 960 pieces and is available exclusively from LEGO UK for £74.99 or from Zavvi (sold out). It may also be available at a markup from third-party resellers on eBay.

10271 Fiat 500 (yellow) also contains 960 pieces and is available from LEGO for US $89.99 | CAN $129.99 | UK £74.99. It may also be available from Amazon and eBay. Be sure to read the TBB Review of this set.

 

8 comments on “LEGO Creator Expert 77942 Fiat 500 limited edition comparison: blue is the new yellow [Review]

  1. Russell Chapman

    The cynic in me suggests the market testing isn’t about yellow vs blue as much as about “can we convince collectors to buy two sets instead of one by offering a small change”. Given how much of the cost of these 18+ sets is in design and development, this seems like a way of maximising profit.

  2. Jimmy

    Yeah, the “market research about color preference” doesn’t pass the sniff test. I’m sure it’s research of some sort, but I find myself doubting the reasons are precisely what Lego says they are.

  3. Tomacco88

    I feel it’s more of a test of how much extra resources it would take to release extra colours of sets than how well they sell. Lego already knows that different people prefer different colours and will get more sales from it. I think they are seeing how much more it costs them in development time/production costs/warehouse space for different parts. The fact it’s only coming to one market is more about the quantity they have made for the test. It could be good and bad. We could be getting more colour options of sets we love but hopefully it doesn’t come at the expense of awesome new sets.

  4. Ewolf

    I was looking at Zavvi today and it does not say anything about being sold out anymore. It has a listing to pre-order the blue Fiat and also lists the release date as November 30th, the same day that Lego supposedly stops selling this set.

  5. winstonheard

    I get cynicism, but don’t forget that other sets are part of this research. I think if they were really doing a money grab, they would’ve used the Porsche or Mustang, since those sets had alternate builds and people would’ve clamored for something like a red targa to partner with their white turbo.
    I think it’ll be cool if they move towards color options for things like 3 in 1 sets or vehicles with modified builds.

  6. Rich

    I rather like the different colours, but I’m biased in that respect, I’ve got 27 different coloured Audi Quattros in addition to the original, plus five different coloured Nissan GTRs. I’ve always been a fan of Lego cars, it’s interesting that Lego have issued a different colour of an existing set.

  7. Jimmy

    Lego sort of did this with the Speed Champions 1974 Porsche 911 Turbo. White in the standalone set 75895, then green in set 75888 (the 2 car set with a 2018 911 RSR)

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.